top of page

OP-ED: UN Chief Guterres Slams Terrorism While Calling Out Israel's Collective Punishment

By: Ahmed Fathi

In a world marred by conflict and strife, the recent remarks by United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres shed light on the complex dynamics surrounding the Israel-Palestine conflict. Guterres unreservedly condemned the terror attacks carried out by Hamas, expressing profound dismay at the reports of sexual violence emanating from the region. However, he also emphasized a crucial point often lost in the fog of war: the brutality of Hamas can never justify Israel's collective punishment of the Palestinian people.

The condemnation of terror acts by Hamas is a clear reaffirmation of the international community's commitment to denounce violence in all its forms. In a stern tone, Guterres made it unequivocally clear that acts of terrorism have no place in the pursuit of a just and lasting resolution to the Israel-Palestine conflict. As the world grapples with the devastating impact of such attacks, it is imperative that responsible actors condemn them without reservation, fostering a united front against the scourge of terrorism.

The reports of sexual violence, appallingly linked to the conflict, further underscore the urgent need for a comprehensive and impartial investigation. The international community must stand together in demanding accountability for these heinous acts, regardless of the perpetrator. Sexual violence as a tool of war is an affront to humanity, and any attempt to use it as a means of achieving political goals must be met with unyielding condemnation.

However, in the same breath, Guterres highlighted a crucial aspect often overshadowed by the immediate horror of terror attacks. The collective punishment meted out by Israel against the Palestinian people must be scrutinized and questioned. While recognizing Israel's right to defend itself, the Secretary General's statement underscores the need for proportionality and adherence to international law. The blanket punitive measures that affect the broader Palestinian population only serve to deepen the cycle of violence, breeding resentment and further complicating the path to peace.

It is essential to distinguish between condemning acts of terror and advocating for justice, even in the midst of a deeply entrenched and emotional conflict. The world must not succumb to the dangerous oversimplification that aligns one-sidedly with either party. True progress towards a resolution demands a nuanced understanding that acknowledges the legitimate security concerns of Israel while addressing the undeniable rights and aspirations of the Palestinian people.

The Israel-Palestine conflict is not a zero-sum game. It is a tragic saga of two peoples with legitimate claims to the same land, both burdened by the weight of history and the consequences of decisions made by generations long past. The path to a lasting solution requires a departure from the futile cycle of blame and retribution, replacing it with a commitment to dialogue, diplomacy, and a shared vision of coexistence.

The international community, and particularly the United Nations, must play a central role in facilitating such dialogue. It is not enough to condemn acts of violence; there must be a sustained and collective effort to create an environment conducive to meaningful negotiations. The United Nations, with its unique position as a global arbiter, should spearhead initiatives that foster trust, bridge divides, and pave the way for a just and equitable resolution.

In conclusion, Secretary General Antonio Guterres's recent statements serve as a stark reminder that the world cannot afford to turn a blind eye to the complexities of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Condemning terrorism and addressing sexual violence are crucial steps, but they must be coupled with a resolute commitment to justice and a recognition of the broader implications of collective punishment. The path to peace requires a delicate balance, a nuanced understanding, and an unwavering dedication to the principles of justice and humanity. The international community must rise to the occasion, working tirelessly to break the cycle of violence and usher in an era of lasting peace for the people of the region.


bottom of page